Used car rankings from MOT data
Most reliable petrol executive cars against petrol cars the same age
We ranked 15 petrol executive cars by how often they failed their MOT at 3 to 15 years old, each against all petrol cars at the same ages. From 1,887,795 DVSA MOT tests in Great Britain, 2022 to 2025.
MOT data updated
First in this list (n=48,770)10.8%
All petrol cars, same ages14.4%
Difference25% lower
MOT tests used1,887,795
First in this list: BMW 5 Series (petrol).
How this ranking works
- Data: DVSA anonymised MOT test data, class 4 normal tests in Great Britain (England, Scotland and Wales), 2022 to 2025. Northern Ireland tests its cars separately and is not included. A fail is a test marked fail or passed after a repair at the test station.
- Measure: share of MOTs failed at each age from 3 to 15 years, pooled, against all petrol cars at the same ages.
- Order: by the fail rate divided by the rate for all petrol cars at the same ages, shown as the difference in per cent. Fail rates rise with age, so a ratio keeps a model seen only at older ages from looking better than it is.
- Comparison: all petrol cars means every class 4 MOT test on petrol except vans, pickups, taxis, campers, van-based people carriers, motorhome and minibus bases and used imports, weighted to each row's own mix of ages.
- Thresholds: every age behind a row here has at least 5,000 tests. A model generation is ranked only with at least 3 ages of 1,000 tests or more, and a row needs at least 3 ages in this list. A list is published only with at least 15 ranked rows.
- Typical mileage: the median odometer reading at each age, averaged over the row's ages by number of tests.
- Segments: from our checked list that puts each DVSA model family in one segment; this list covers large family and executive cars. Families that change body type between generations without a split in the data are left out.
- Fuel: as DVSA records it on each test. Each row is one model generation on petrol; where a model is also sold with other fuels, the row is named with the fuel and its figures differ from the model's all-fuel MOT page.
- Vans, pickups, taxis, campers, van-based people carriers, motorhome and minibus bases, and models sold here mainly as used imports are left out of car lists.
- Years in brackets are the first-use years of a model generation.
The ranking
| # | Model | MOT fail rate | All petrol cars, same ages | Difference | Ages | Tests (n) | Typical mileage |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | BMW 5 Series (petrol)Common problems · Recalls · ULEZ | 10.8% | 14.4% | 25% lower | 3 to 7 | 48,770 | 36,700 miles |
| 2 | Audi A5 (petrol)Common problems · Recalls · ULEZ | 17.4% | 23.1% | 25% lower | 3 to 15 | 201,416 | 58,300 miles |
| 3 | BMW 3 Series (petrol)Common problems · Recalls · ULEZ | 20.4% | 26.7% | 24% lower | 3 to 15 | 380,050 | 64,100 miles |
| 4 | Mercedes-Benz C-Class (petrol)Common problems · Recalls · ULEZ | 19.2% | 25.0% | 23% lower | 3 to 15 | 373,360 | 56,900 miles |
| 5 | BMW 4 Series (petrol)Common problems · Recalls · ULEZ | 13.6% | 17.7% | 23% lower | 3 to 10 | 145,075 | 41,900 miles |
| 6 | Audi A4 (petrol)Common problems · Recalls · ULEZ | 17.5% | 21.7% | 19% lower | 3 to 15 | 244,759 | 57,500 miles |
| 7 | Toyota Avensis (petrol)Common problems · Recalls · ULEZ | 32.7% | 39.0% | 16% lower | 12 to 15 | 39,959 | 98,300 miles |
| 8 | Skoda Superb (petrol)Common problems · Recalls · ULEZ | 12.8% | 14.5% | 12% lower | 3 to 7 | 38,436 | 39,900 miles |
| 9 | Jaguar XE (petrol)Common problems · Recalls · ULEZ | 15.1% | 17.1% | 12% lower | 4 to 8 | 40,199 | 36,500 miles |
| 10 | Ford Mondeo (petrol)Common problems · Recalls · ULEZ | 32.0% | 35.4% | 10% lower | 7 to 15 | 49,851 | 86,500 miles |
| 11 | Volkswagen Passat (petrol)Common problems · Recalls · ULEZ | 11.5% | 12.3% | 7% lower | 3 to 5 | 18,158 | 35,300 miles |
| 12 | Mazda 6 (petrol)Common problems · Recalls · ULEZ | 25.8% | 27.3% | 5% lower | 3 to 15 | 95,335 | 69,600 miles |
| 13 | Mercedes-Benz E-Class (petrol)Common problems · Recalls · ULEZ | 14.9% | 14.7% | 2% higher | 3 to 7 | 41,404 | 33,600 miles |
| 14 | Vauxhall Insignia (petrol)Common problems · Recalls · ULEZ | 27.4% | 26.6% | 3% higher | 3 to 15 | 149,583 | 69,000 miles |
| 15 | Citroen C5 (petrol)Common problems · Recalls · ULEZ | 15.8% | 12.2% | 30% higher | 3 to 5 | 21,440 | 26,000 miles |
What stands out
- BMW 5 Series (petrol) comes first: 10.8% against 14.4% for all petrol cars at the same ages, 25% lower (n=48,770).
- 12 of the 15 ranked petrol executive cars fail less often than all petrol cars at the same ages.
- In the 15 shown, the difference from all petrol cars runs from 25% lower to 30% higher.
- 4 other rows are within 5% of the first on the difference, so read close positions as level rather than as a strict order.
Read this with care. A fail rate is not a measure of build quality. How far cars are driven, how they are used and how well owners maintain them all change it, and wear items such as tyres and brake pads are common fails. Compare a model only with cars of the same age. Methodology and limits.
More rankings
All used car rankings · MOT fail rates by make and model · Common problems by model · Recalls by model · ULEZ by model
Looking at one car?
A ranking describes model generations, not the car in front of you. The VetTheCar Buying Report reads one car's MOT history, mileage and recalls and sets them against cars like it.
Source
Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0. Source: DVSA anonymised MOT test data, class 4 normal MOT tests, 2022 to 2025. MOT data updated 28 September 2026.
Not affiliated with or endorsed by DVSA. How we calculate these figures · Data sources